# How to Tell If a Well Pump Is Bad: 6 Checks Before You Pull It

> How to tell if a well pump is bad: rule out the breaker, gauge, switch, tank and control box, then test amps and insulation. Franklin's limits inside.

URL: https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/how-to-tell-if-a-well-pump-is-bad/

How-To

Most no-water and low-pressure calls trace to parts above ground. Work through the breaker, gauge, switch, tank and control box first; only amp draw and insulation tests at the wellhead can condemn the pump itself.

How to tell if a well pump is bad: rule out everything above ground first. Check the breaker and voltage (within **±10%** of the motor rating), the pressure gauge, the switch contacts, the tank's air charge and the control box. If all pass, amp draw and an insulation reading below **0.5 megohm** point to the pump or its cable.

Key takeaways

- Franklin Electric's troubleshooting table lists seven causes for a motor that will not start; only two, a bound pump and a defective cable or motor, are down the well ( [Franklin Electric AIM Manual, 2023](https://www.geotechenv.com/Manuals/Franklin_AIM/Electric_Submersible_Motors_AIM.pdf)).
- Voltage at the line terminals must be within **±10%** of the motor's rated voltage, or the fault is the power supply, not the pump ( [Franklin AIM, Table 17](https://www.geotechenv.com/Manuals/Franklin_AIM/Electric_Submersible_Motors_AIM.pdf)).
- With the motor and drop cable in the well, Franklin rates **0.5–2.0 megohms** as good condition and **less than 0.5** as insulation damage to locate and repair ( [Franklin AIM, p. 37](https://www.geotechenv.com/Manuals/Franklin_AIM/Electric_Submersible_Motors_AIM.pdf)).
- A sand-bound pump draws **3 to 6 times** normal amps until the overload trips, per the same table.
- A waterlogged tank mimics a failing pump with rapid switch clicking and short cycling, and Boshart warns it "will burn out your pump" ( [Boshart](https://support.boshart.com/how-can-i-tell-if-my-pressure-tank-is-waterlogged)).
- Above-ground fixes are cheap: a pressure switch runs **$100–$300** and a control box **$200–$400** installed, against **$1,800–$4,500** for a new submersible at Parker County depths ( [our repair cost guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-repair-cost/); [our replacement cost guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/learn/well-pump-replacement-cost/)).

[Water Well Drilling Weatherford](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/) hears it on almost every no-water call: how to tell if a well pump is bad before paying to pull it. The short answer is to suspect the pump last. Most of the parts that fail sit above ground, cost a few hundred dollars and can be checked in minutes. Below are six checks in order, the numbers a technician uses to condemn a pump, and the point where a [well pump repair](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/services/well-pump-repair/) call is the right move.

## What are the signs of a bad well pump?

The signs are no water, weak pressure, a pump that never shuts off, a tripping breaker, and air or sediment at the tap. Each one can also come from the switch, the tank, the controls or the well, so a sign tells you where to look, not what to replace.

This table maps each symptom to its likely causes, in the order a technician usually checks them. It follows Franklin Electric’s troubleshooting table in the [AIM Manual](https://www.geotechenv.com/Manuals/Franklin_AIM/Electric_Submersible_Motors_AIM.pdf), the motor maker’s own guide for installers.

| Symptom | Check first | Pump itself if… |
| --- | --- | --- |
| No water, pump silent | Breaker, voltage, pressure switch, control box | Power reaches the motor leads and it still will not start |
| Pump hums, no water, breaker trips | Control box capacitor or relay | Amps run 3 to 6 times normal: a bound or seized pump |
| Pump starts every few seconds | Tank air charge, switch setting, check valve, leaks | Rarely the pump |
| Pump runs and never shuts off | Leaks, switch contacts, well level | Pressure will not climb with the house shut off: worn pump |
| Weak pressure everywhere | Filter, tank charge, switch setting | Pump cannot reach cut-off with no water running |
| Air or sand at the tap | Well level, pump depth | Sand has worn the impellers |

Our [no water from well guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/learn/no-water-from-well/) covers the breaker-and-gauge triage for the first row, and [why a well pump runs constantly](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-running-constantly/) covers the fourth.

The six checks in order, cheapest and safest first. Illustration, not a photo of a real job.

## How do you check the breaker and voltage first?

Look at the pump breaker, then have the voltage measured. Franklin’s table puts “no power or incorrect voltage” first under a motor that does not start, and says voltage at the line terminals “must be ± 10% of rated voltage.” Outside that band, call the power company, not a pump crew.

A tripped breaker you can reset once. If it trips again, leave it off: a breaker that will not hold is a symptom, and Franklin lists blown fuses, loose or corroded connections and a defective motor or cable as causes. Lightning is another; our [lightning damage guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/lightning-damage-well-pump/) covers what a strike does to a pump and its controls.

InspectApedia’s checklist for a pump that will not run follows the same order: water supply valves, then power at the breaker, then the gauge and switch ([InspectApedia](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Water-Pump-Wont-Turn-On.php)). It warns that testing live circuits is dangerous for untrained people. Checking the breaker is yours; measuring live voltage belongs to an electrician or a licensed pump installer.

## What does the pressure gauge tell you about the pump?

The gauge separates “no start” from “no pressure.” If the needle sits below cut-in and the pump is silent, power or the controls are failing to start it. If the pump runs but the needle never climbs to cut-off, the pump, a leak or the well is the limit.

InspectApedia gives a typical cut-in of 20 or 30 psi: run water, watch the gauge fall to that number, and listen for the pump to start. It also warns that gauges clog and fail, so a reading that makes no sense should be checked against a second gauge before anyone condemns a pump.

Franklin’s test for a worn pump uses the switch, not a meter. Worn pump symptoms look like a drop-pipe leak or a low well level, and the manual says to “reduce pressure switch setting, if pump shuts off worn parts may be the fault.” A pump that can still reach 40 psi but not 50 is losing output. A pump that cannot build pressure at any setting needs a technician.

## How do you tell a bad pressure switch from a bad pump?

Watch what happens at the contacts. If the pump runs whenever the contacts close and stops when they open, the pump is working and the switch decides when it runs. Burned, pitted or welded contacts and a clogged sensing port are the switch’s common failures.

Closing the contacts by hand is not a clean test. When a reader asked InspectApedia in October 2020 whether the pump had failed because closing the contacts manually changed nothing, the editor replied that badly burned contacts might not conduct, and suggested checking voltage at the switch terminals with a meter ([InspectApedia](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Water-Pump-Wont-Turn-On.php)). That is a job for someone qualified to work on live circuits. Franklin’s table lists a defective pressure switch as a cause of a motor that will not start and of one that starts too often, and says improper contact can leave the motor with less than line voltage.

A switch is the cheapest part on this list. Septic & Well Pro’s 2026 guides, summarised in our [well pump repair cost guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-repair-cost/), put a replacement at $100 to $300 installed. Our [pressure switch walkthrough](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/how-to-adjust-a-well-pressure-switch/) covers settings and the cover-off safety steps.

## How do you rule out the pressure tank?

Check the air charge. With the breaker off and a faucet open until the gauge reads zero, the tank’s air valve should read 2 psi below cut-in. If water spits from the valve, the bladder has failed, and the tank, not the pump, is your problem.

Boshart’s knowledge base lists six signs of a waterlogged tank: rapid clicking at the switch, short cycling, a top that feels cold or wet, no hollow sound when you knock on the upper half, a jumping gauge needle and pulsing pressure in the shower ([Boshart](https://support.boshart.com/how-can-i-tell-if-my-pressure-tank-is-waterlogged)). It warns that “a waterlogged pressure tank will burn out your pump” and that pump warranties usually exclude that failure. Our [signs of a bad pressure tank guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/learn/signs-of-a-bad-pressure-tank/) goes deeper.

Short cycling matters because starts wear a pump out. Franklin’s starts table allows 300 starts a day for single-phase motors up to 0.75 hp and 100 a day for 1 to 5.5 hp, and says to run a motor at least one minute per start to shed the heat of starting. Our [well pump short cycling explainer](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-short-cycling/) covers the switch, leak and check valve causes too.

Key numbers from the Franklin Electric AIM Manual (2023) and our analysis of TWDB driller reports. Illustration, not a photo.

## How do you check the control box on a 3-wire pump?

Find out which motor you have. Franklin’s manual describes 2-wire motors with solid-state starting controls built into the motor, and 3-wire motors that start through an above-ground control box with capacitors and a relay. On a 3-wire system, that box is a common failure and it can be tested without pulling anything. Our [2-wire vs 3-wire well pump comparison](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/2-wire-vs-3-wire-well-pump/) explains how to tell which one you have.

The classic sign is a hum with no water, or a motor that starts and trips its overload. Franklin lists a control box malfunction under both “motor does not start” and “motor runs but overload protector trips,” and adds that sun or another heat source can trip the box’s protectors: the box “must not be hot to touch.” [RC Worst’s Franklin control box guide](https://www.rcworst.com/blog/How-to-Troubleshoot-Franklin-Electric-Control-Boxes-1-5-15-HP) has a technician check supply voltage first, then the capacitors with an ohmmeter, then the relay.

The price gap is why this check comes before the pump. A capacitor or relay runs $150 to $400 installed and a whole control box $200 to $400, per the guides in our [repair cost article](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-repair-cost/).

## What tests prove the pump itself is bad?

Four tests at the wellhead decide it: line voltage, running amps in every motor wire, insulation resistance to ground, and winding resistance. Franklin says to complete these “before removing the motor from the well.” All four need a meter and the power disconnected for the resistance tests, so this is the licensed pro’s step.

Insulation resistance is the clearest number. Franklin’s table, measured with a 500-volt megohmmeter on the motor plus drop cable in the well, reads like this:

| Reading (motor and cable in the well) | What Franklin says it means |
| --- | --- |
| 2.0 megohms or more | New motor |
| 0.50 to 2.0 megohms | Motor in good condition |
| Less than 0.50 megohm | Insulation damage: locate and repair |

A low reading can be the cable rather than the motor. Franklin and [RC Worst](https://www.rcworst.com/blog/Troubleshooting-4-Submersible-Motor-Insulation-Windings-Resistance) both say to check that the cable insulation at the well seal is not pinched. Winding resistance then tells the technician whether a winding is shorted (reading low) or open (reading high).

Amps tell the rest. Franklin says a sand-bound or misaligned pump draws “3 to 6 times higher than normal until the overload trips,” and that running current above the motor’s rating points to a worn pump or motor. Only then is the answer to pull the pump.

0.5 megohm Below this, with the motor and cable in the well, Franklin calls it insulation damage to locate and repair. Source: Franklin Electric AIM Manual, 2023, Insulation Resistance Readings

## Is it the pump or is the well running low?

If the pump runs, delivers air or sputters, then recovers after a rest, suspect the well. Franklin’s table lists “low water level in well” under a motor that runs continuously and says to shut off the pump, let the well recover and check static and drawdown levels from the wellhead.

Depth matters here. New wells near Weatherford finish with water a median of about 110 ft down, from our [analysis of TWDB driller reports](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/static-water-level-in-a-well/), and summer use pulls that lower. A pump set too close to a falling water level sucks air before it fails. Our [is my well going dry guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/learn/is-my-well-going-dry/) covers the signs and the fixes, from lowering the pump to [well deepening](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/services/well-deepening/).

## What have other well owners found?

Public Q&A shows how often the pump gets blamed for something else, and how often the cause is never confirmed.

- **A tank first, then a pump.** A reader letter on InspectApedia describes losing pressure, then getting intermittent flow for about a day. A contractor found a ruptured tank bladder and fitted a new tank for about $600, then sold a new pump when the pump would not start, for a total of “$2000 and some change.” The editor called that steep for an in-house pump but plausible for a submersible that had to be pulled ( [InspectApedia](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Cost_to_Repair_Replace_Water_Tank.php)).
- **A breaker that brought it back.** A reader who lost pressure in December 2015 cycled the pump breaker off and on, and the pump started at once, though the breaker had not tripped. The editor suggested a developing motor problem or an intermittent, moisture-dependent short, which would be unsafe, and advised an electrician if it recurred ( [InspectApedia](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Submersible-Pump-Repair-FAQs2.php)).
- **An 8-year-old pump losing pressure.** A reader in August 2011 had “lots of water” but falling pressure from a pump about 8 years old, after a muddy surge into the cistern. The editor listed a damaged impeller, mineral crud in the impeller, or an inlet or outlet blockage, and suggested measuring output pressure before pulling the pump. No result was posted.

None of these is a Texas case, and none is our job. They show the pattern: the cheap parts fail often, and an unverified pump replacement is an expensive guess.

## Author’s take: what would I check first?

This section is the author’s analysis of the sources above, written by [Chris Fugate](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/about/chris-fugate/), a water well driller with 24 years of experience. It draws conclusions from the cited evidence and does not describe any particular customer or job.

**Make the pump prove it is bad.** Only two of the seven no-start causes in Franklin’s own table are down the well. A breaker, a switch, a capacitor or a tank costs a fraction of a pull, so they get checked before anyone brings a rig.

**Ask for the numbers.** Anyone recommending a new submersible should be able to tell you the voltage, the running amps against the motor’s rating, and the megohm reading. A reading under 0.5 megohm or amps far over rating is a reason to pull. “It’s old” is not, as our [pump lifespan guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/how-long-does-a-well-pump-last/) explains.

**Fix the cause with the pump.** A waterlogged tank or a well running low will kill the next pump too. If the pump does come out, the tank charge and the water level get checked the same day.

## When should you call a pro, and what will it cost?

Call when the breaker trips again after one reset, the pump hums without pumping, water spits from the tank’s air valve, or you cannot confirm the power is off. Texas requires a license to install or repair a pump on a water well ([TDLR](https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/media/pdf/water-well-drillers-and-pump-installers-at-a-glance.pdf)).

A diagnostic visit runs $75 to $200 in the guides behind our [repair cost article](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-repair-cost/), and most single-part repairs land between $100 and $500. If the tests do condemn the pump, a submersible replacement at Parker County depths typically runs $1,800 to $4,500, per our [well pump replacement cost guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/learn/well-pump-replacement-cost/), and our [repair or replace guide](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/learn/repair-or-replace-well-pump/) explains how to decide. With no water tonight, use [emergency well pump repair](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/emergency-well-pump-repair/), or start with the [well problem checker](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/well-problem-checker/).

## How was this guide researched?

This guide is built on Franklin Electric’s 2023 AIM Manual, the installer reference for its submersible motors, read in full for the troubleshooting table, insulation readings and starts table. It adds RC Worst’s motor-testing guide, InspectApedia’s pump diagnostic pages and reader Q&A, Boshart’s tank guide and a This Old House diagnostic article. Repair prices are the Septic & Well Pro 2026 figures already used on this site; they are not Texas quotes. The 110 ft water level is the median from our own analysis of Texas Water Development Board driller reports. Reddit was blocked from our fetch tool and two forum threads returned errors, so no Reddit or TractorByNet posts are used. There are no field tests or measurements of our own here. Your motor’s manual wins if it differs from Franklin’s.

## Frequently asked questions

**How do you know if your well pump is going bad?**

The usual signs are no water, weak pressure that the switch and tank do not explain, a pump that runs without shutting off, a breaker that trips, and sputtering or dirty water. None proves the pump is bad by itself. Rule out the breaker, gauge, switch, tank and control box first.

**How do I test my well pump without pulling it out?**

A technician tests it at the wellhead or control box. Franklin's manual lists four tests to run before removing a motor: line-to-line voltage, amperage in all motor wires, insulation resistance to ground, and winding resistance. Together they show whether the motor, cable or controls are at fault.

**How do I know if it's my well pump or pressure switch?**

If the pump starts when the switch contacts close and stops when they open, the pump works and the switch is in charge. Burned contacts and a clogged sensing port are common switch faults. InspectApedia notes that badly burned contacts may not conduct even when closed, so a technician confirms with a voltage reading at the switch terminals.

**How do I know if it's my well pump or pressure tank?**

A waterlogged tank makes the switch click on and off quickly, the pump short cycle and pressure pulse in the shower. Boshart lists a dull sound when you knock on the tank's upper half and a cold, wet top as further signs. Check the air valve: water there means the tank, not the pump.

**How do I tell if my well is dry or the pump is bad?**

A pump that runs, sputters air and recovers after resting points to the well. Franklin's table says a pump exceeding well capacity should be shut off and the well allowed to recover. A pump that gets no power, hums or trips the breaker points to the pump or controls.

**What does a bad well pump sound like?**

A hum with no water often means a failed start capacitor or relay or a stuck pump. Grinding or squealing can mean worn bearings, according to This Old House's well diagnostic guide. Rapid clicking at the tank is usually the pressure switch reacting to a waterlogged tank.

**Can a well pump work but be bad?**

Yes. Franklin notes that worn pump symptoms resemble a drop-pipe leak or low well level: the pump runs but builds pressure slowly or not at all. Its suggested check is to lower the switch setting; if the pump then shuts off, worn parts may be the cause.

**Should I replace a well pump myself in Texas?**

No. Texas licenses pump installers through TDLR, and installing or repairing a pump on a water well is licensed work. You can check the breaker, read the gauge and test the tank's air charge yourself; leave the voltage, amp and insulation tests to a licensed pro.

Sources

1. [Franklin Electric, AIM Manual: 60 Hz Submersible Systems, 2023 edition (Table 17 System Troubleshooting; Insulation Resistance Readings, p. 37; Frequency of Starts, p. 3)](https://www.geotechenv.com/Manuals/Franklin_AIM/Electric_Submersible_Motors_AIM.pdf)
2. [RC Worst & Co., Troubleshooting 4" Submersible Motor Insulation and Windings Resistance (Oct. 26, 2017)](https://www.rcworst.com/blog/Troubleshooting-4-Submersible-Motor-Insulation-Windings-Resistance)
3. [InspectApedia (Daniel Friedman), Why won't the water pump run?](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Water-Pump-Wont-Turn-On.php)
4. [InspectApedia, Submersible well pump diagnostic questions and answers (reader questions 2011 to 2017)](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Submersible-Pump-Repair-FAQs2.php)
5. [InspectApedia, Cost to repair or replace a water tank (reader letter)](https://inspectapedia.com/water/Cost_to_Repair_Replace_Water_Tank.php)
6. [RC Worst & Co., How to Troubleshoot Franklin Electric Control Boxes (1/3 to 15 HP)](https://www.rcworst.com/blog/How-to-Troubleshoot-Franklin-Electric-Control-Boxes-1-5-15-HP)
7. [Boshart Industries, How can I tell if my pressure tank is waterlogged?](https://support.boshart.com/how-can-i-tell-if-my-pressure-tank-is-waterlogged)
8. [This Old House, How to Diagnose Problems With Well Water Systems (updated May 26, 2026)](https://www.thisoldhouse.com/plumbing/how-to-diagnose-problems-with-well-water-systems)
9. [Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation, Water Well Drillers and Pump Installers at a Glance](https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/media/pdf/water-well-drillers-and-pump-installers-at-a-glance.pdf)
10. [Texas Water Development Board, Submitted Drillers Reports](https://www.twdb.texas.gov/groundwater/data/drillersdb.asp)

## More from the news desk

- Explainer **[2 Wire vs 3 Wire Well Pump: Differences, Cost and Which to Choose](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/2-wire-vs-3-wire-well-pump/).**
- Explainer **[Well Maintenance Cost: What a Year of Upkeep Runs in 2026](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-maintenance-cost/).**
- Explainer **[Well Pump Short Cycling: Why It Happens and How to Stop It](https://waterwelldrillingweatherford.com/news/well-pump-short-cycling/).**

## Ask about your well

Faster by phone, any hour: [(817) 382-3840](tel:+18173823840)
