Yes, methane has been documented in some Parker County water wells. A University of Texas at Austin study of more than 450 wells found 11 wells in Parker and Hood counties above 10 mg/L and traced them mainly to shallow natural gas, though a separate study and the 2010 EPA order show the cause was contested. Dissolved methane isn't toxic to drink, but it can build up and ignite. A lab test tells you your level, and wells above 10 mg/L warrant venting and monitoring.
Water Well Drilling Weatherford gets asked about methane in well water mostly by people buying property in south Parker County who remember the headlines. The history is real, the science is contested, and the practical answer for a well owner is simpler than either.
What happened in Parker County
In 2010, the US EPA ordered Range Resources, which was drilling Barnett Shale gas wells near Weatherford, to supply drinking water to two residents whose well water contained methane. The EPA later withdrew the order in a settlement, and in May 2014 the Railroad Commission of Texas, which regulates oil and gas, issued an 11-page report saying the evidence was insufficient to implicate the driller. The Texas Tribune reported in 2014 that methane levels had risen in 5 of the 7 wells tested between 2010 and September 2013, and that independent scientists were divided on the cause. The EPA’s Office of Inspector General confirmed in its December 2013 report that the agency withdrew the emergency order but kept monitoring for widespread contamination.
The science since then points mostly to a natural, shallow source:
- University of Texas at Austin, 2017. Researchers at the Bureau of Economic Geology sampled more than 450 water wells across 12 counties of the western Barnett Shale. About 85 percent had methane below 0.1 mg/L. A cluster of 11 wells in Parker and Hood counties exceeded 10 mg/L, and the team traced that gas to shallow natural gas in the Strawn Group, not to fracking in the deeper Barnett Shale. They found no correlation with distance to hydraulically fractured wells, but did not fully rule out some leakage from deeper reservoirs.
- PNAS, 2014. A noble-gas study of 20 Barnett-area samples and 113 Marcellus-area samples found one Texas cluster of fugitive gas. The paper says the contamination likely came from Strawn gas that moved up the annulus of a gas well, which is a well-construction problem rather than fracking. It does not name the county for its Texas wells.
Both studies point at the Strawn, a formation that sits above the Barnett. They differ on whether a gas well’s construction gave the gas a path to water wells. For a well owner deciding what to do today, the source matters less than the level.
What the numbers mean
Dissolved methane is measured by a lab in milligrams per liter. The US Office of Surface Mining’s widely used guidance:
| Dissolved methane | Suggested action |
|---|---|
| Under 10 mg/L | Periodic monitoring |
| 10–28 mg/L | Monitor regularly; remove ignition sources from the wellhead area; consider venting |
| Over 28 mg/L | Take immediate action to reduce methane |
Penn State Extension adds why this matters: methane in water is not toxic, but it forms an explosive mixture in air at 5 to 15 percent by volume, and how much dissolved gas gets there depends on water temperature, ventilation and air movement. Cold groundwater around 50°F holds about 28 mg/L; once the water reaches surface pressure and warms above 58°F, very little stays dissolved. That is why a vented cap helps and why a closed pump house is the risk.
Signs that justify a test
- A gas or “rotten” smell at the wellhead, or water that fizzes or sputters
- Sudden sputtering taps or air in the lines
- Property near past gas development in south Parker or Hood County
- Buying a property where you want a baseline
Methane testing uses a special sealed sample, so it’s collected at the wellhead and delivered to the lab quickly. We add it to a standard well water test on request; for typical lab fees on the standard panel, see well water test cost in Texas.
If your level is high
- Vent the well. A vented, screened well cap lets gas escape outdoors rather than into the pump house or home. Penn State Extension puts vented caps at typically under $100, with limited capacity at high levels.
- Ventilate enclosed spaces. Well houses and pump pits should never be sealed tight on a methane-bearing well. If the wellhead is in a basement, the cap should be sealed and the vent piped outdoors.
- Add a detector. Methane is lighter than air, so a gas detector goes near the ceiling. Penn State lists home detectors under $100.
- Treat if needed. Aeration (air-stripping) systems remove methane before water enters the house, and can also strip hydrogen sulfide. Penn State puts installation at about $1,500 to $5,000, plus routine maintenance; iron or manganese may need pretreatment first. If the water also smells like sulfur, see rotten egg smell in well water.
- Retest. Levels can change, and a trend is more useful than a single number. The 2014 Tribune report found rising levels in 5 of 7 wells over three years.
Who should test, and how
Have an accredited lab test it, and have the sample taken at the wellhead rather than from a kitchen tap, because gas escapes as water warms and depressurizes. Penn State advises lab personnel, not the homeowner, collect the sample. If you are buying a house in south Parker County, ask for a dissolved methane result as part of the well inspection along with the standard panel.
Bottom line
If you smell gas at the well, see bubbling or sputtering water, or live near past gas development in south Parker or Hood County, get a dissolved methane test. Below 10 mg/L, monitor it. Between 10 and 28 mg/L, vent the well and remove ignition sources. Above 28 mg/L, act immediately.
Questions about your own well? Call (817) 382-3840. A person answers 24/7.
Sources
- Texas Tribune, Methane inquiry closes, but questions linger (June 20, 2014)
- UT Austin, researchers link methane in Parker and Hood groundwater to natural sources (March 8, 2017)
- US EPA Office of Inspector General, report on the Range Resources emergency order (December 20, 2013)
- Darrah et al., Noble gases identify the mechanisms of fugitive gas contamination in drinking-water wells overlying the Marcellus and Barnett Shales (PNAS, 2014)
- Penn State Extension, methane gas and its removal from water wells